Staffies: Rewriting the Narrative on Misunderstood Breeds

Written by Australian Dog Lover 13:09:00 - 0 Comments

More than a Label: Understanding and Advocating for Staffies and Pitbull-Type Dogs

There are few types of dogs in Australia more misunderstood—or more unfairly judged—than those labelled “Staffy” or “Pitbull.” For many of us, they’re cherished companions—emotionally sensitive, enthusiastic, and deeply connected to their humans. And yet, these dogs face stigma, discrimination, and breed-specific legislation that places blame before understanding.

As a dog behaviour consultant, Camille Hartnett from Trail Sniffers has seen first-hand how these harmful myths impact both dogs and their guardians. This article isn’t about excusing behaviour. It’s about expanding our understanding of it—through education, science, and compassion. 

When we stop reducing these dogs to headlines or harmful myths, we begin to see what’s always been there: emotionally driven, intelligent individuals shaped by more than their breed label.

Understanding the Stigma

Let’s begin with a common misconception: “Pitbull” is not a breed. 

In Australia, it’s a term often used to describe any short-coated, blocky-headed dog with a muscular frame — including American Staffordshire Terriers, Staffordshire Bull Terriers, Bull Arabs, American Bulldogs, and countless crossbreeds.

When dogs are labelled based on looks alone, it opens the door to misidentification and bias. This becomes especially harmful when paired with media sensationalism. Incidents involving bully breeds tend to receive disproportionate coverage — often stripped of context — which fuels public fear. 

Add confirmation bias to the mix, and we begin to see how a single stereotype can snowball into widespread discrimination.

But appearance isn’t behaviour. And breed alone does not determine how a dog will respond to the world around them. 

Like any dog, their behaviour is shaped by learning history, genetics, environment, and emotional wellbeing. When these dogs are misunderstood, unsupported, or placed in environments that don’t meet their needs, behaviour struggles may arise — not because of their breed, but because of unmet needs.

Understanding Behaviour Through the L.E.G.S. Framework

To truly understand behaviour, we must look deeper than surface labels. That’s where the L.E.G.S. model — developed by applied ethologist Kim Brophey — becomes invaluable. This framework explores the four key influences on behaviour: Learning, Environment, Genetics, and Self.

• Learning: Every dog carries a behavioural history.

Reinforcement patterns, early experiences, trauma, or even well-intentioned but ineffective training can impact how a dog reacts today. A Staffy-type dog who barks or lunges on lead may not be “aggressive” — they may have learned, through experience, that reacting is how they regain space or safety.

• Environment: Dogs are constantly responding to their surroundings. 

Busy streets, off-lead dogs, overwhelming social setups, or lack of decompression can all result in reactive or aroused behaviours. Staffy-type dogs often have high emotional thresholds, but they’re not immune to stress. Their environment — including noise, routine, movement, and unpredictability — can greatly influence their ability to cope.

• Genetics: This is where much of the misunderstanding begins. 

Staffy and Pitbull-type dogs were originally bred for high-intensity roles — including guarding property, hunting large prey, and in some cases, fighting other animals. These were dogs selected for strength, physical resilience, emotional intensity, and unwavering focus on the task at hand.

Many of these breeds also have incredibly high prey drive, meaning they are biologically wired to chase, grab, or hold onto fast-moving objects — whether that’s livestock, a toy, or a running dog. This doesn’t make them dangerous. It makes them driven.

Genetics don’t excuse behaviour, but they do explain why some dogs are more likely to struggle in environments that conflict with their original purpose. 

Asking a high-drive, task-bred dog to calmly navigate an overstimulating suburban footpath without adequate outlets is unfair — and often sets everyone up for failure.

Honouring a dog’s genetic blueprint doesn’t mean allowing unsafe behaviour. 

It means understanding their needs, offering appropriate outlets, and making sure our expectations align with who they are, not just what we want from them.

• Self: Each dog is a unique individual. 

Pain, underlying medical conditions, developmental stage, nutrition, sleep, and emotional regulation all play a role in behaviour. A young, sensitive Staffy with unmet enrichment needs will likely struggle in public environments not because they’re “bad,” but because their body and brain aren’t in balance.

Why They Can Make Wonderful Pets

Despite the stigma, Staffy and Pitbull-type dogs can make incredible family companions when matched with the right home, support, and outlets for their needs.

These dogs often thrive in environments where they are included in daily life, given purposeful activities, and provided with consistency. Their strong engagement with humans means they can excel in dog sports, scent work, hiking, or even just structured enrichment routines at home.

When guardians understand their breed traits — including drive, sensitivity, and task focus — they can channel those traits into positive outlets. Tug games can meet their need for grip and strength. Scent work can tap into their focus and mental stamina. Structured training builds communication and trust.

The truth is, these dogs can be affectionate, playful, and deeply connected to their people. But they are not a “set and forget” breed. They need guardians who are committed to understanding them, providing boundaries without fear, and embracing their energetic, intelligent nature.

With the right approach, these dogs are not just “good pets” — they are incredible partners in adventure, enrichment, and daily life.

Common Challenges — and How to Support Them

Many guardians of Staffy and Pitbull-type dogs face very real challenges. This doesn’t mean these dogs are inherently difficult. It means we need to shift how we support them.

It’s also important to recognise that these challenges are not exclusive to Staffies or Pitbull-type dogs.

• Reactivity and Over-Arousal on Walks:

It’s common for these dogs to respond to stimuli — other dogs, fast movement, unfamiliar people — with barking, lunging, or vocalisation. This is often a mix of frustration and fear, especially in environments that feel unsafe.

✔️ Use Y-front harnesses and long lines to allow decompression.

✔️ Avoid busy footpaths or dog-heavy areas during peak times.

✔️ Teach disengagement behaviours like “Look at That” or “Find It”.

✔️ Offer sniff-based walks to reduce cortisol and promote calm exploration.

• Separation-Related Distress:

These dogs often form strong emotional bonds, and many have histories of rehoming, abandonment, or trauma. Sudden absences can trigger pacing, destruction, or vocalisation.

✔️ Create predictable routines around coming and going

✔️ Use enrichment tools (e.g., lick mats, snuffle boxes) to promote relaxation

✔️ Build independence gradually through short absences

✔️ Avoid using punishment — it adds confusion and stress

• Impulse Control and Arousal Regulation:

Jumping up, mouthy greetings, and pulling on lead aren’t signs of defiance — they’re usually symptoms of over-arousal and underdeveloped self-regulation.

✔️ Teach alternative behaviours through positive reinforcement.

✔️ Reinforce calm body language, especially before greetings or transitions.

✔️Offer breed-appropriate enrichment like tug, flirt pole, or puzzle feeders.

✔️ Focus on building tolerance for frustration through structured games.

• Public Stigma and Misinformation:

Sadly, many guardians feel the weight of judgement in public spaces. Strangers cross the street. Comments are made. Assumptions are drawn before a word is spoken.

✔️ Use advocacy gear like vests or leash sleeves with “Give Me Space” or “In Training” messages.

✔️ Create safe distance from other dogs and people to reduce conflict.

✔️ Speak confidently and calmly to others if your dog is being misjudged.

✔️ Find a community of people who understand and validate your experiences.

Punishment and aversive tools may suppress behaviour short-term, but they don’t build understanding or safety. They increase stress, erode trust, and fail to teach dogs what to do. Kindness isn’t permissive — it’s effective, humane, and evidence-based.

Myth-Busting: Let’s Set the Record Straight

• “Pitbulls turn without warning.” Dogs don’t “snap.” They communicate discomfort long before escalation — we just need to learn how to listen.

• “Staffies aren’t good with children.” There’s no breed rule here. Dogs of any breed can be safe and appropriate around children if they are supported, supervised, and their needs are being met.

• “Once a dog shows aggression, they can’t be trusted again.” False. Behaviour is fluid. With proper support and guidance, dogs can learn new responses and thrive.

• “These dogs need a strong hand.” No. They need strong relationships. Modern, evidence-based training focuses on building trust, understanding behaviour, and reinforcing success — not controlling it.

What Guardians Can Do: Advocacy in Action

Everyday guardians play a powerful role in reshaping the narrative. Here’s how to advocate — not just for your dog, but for all misunderstood breeds:

• Learn canine communication. Understanding stress signals, displacement behaviours, and appeasement gestures helps prevent reactivity and builds connection.

• Use communication gear. Leash sleeves, shirts, and harness patches help others understand your dog’s needs at a glance.

• Speak up respectfully. Correct misinformation when you hear it — whether it’s at the dog park, vet clinic, or family BBQ.

• Celebrate your dog’s strengths. Share your wins. Talk about your training journey. Show the joy and the nuance — not just the polished moments.

• Support others. Whether it’s encouraging a fellow guardian, sharing a resource, or advocating for inclusive legislation — community matters.

Final Thoughts: Rewriting the Narrative

These dogs are more than a label. They are not a threat. They are not dangerous by default. They are thinking, feeling, emotional beings — just like every other dog.

When we stop viewing behaviour as a problem and start seeing it as communication, everything changes. We stop asking, “What’s wrong with this dog?” and start asking:

“What do they need from me right now?”

The truth is, education and empathy save lives. We owe these dogs a better story — one that reflects who they really are, not who the world assumes them to be.

Let’s be the ones who write it.

About Our Writer

Camille Hartnett is a Certified Family Dog Mediator, Aggression in Dogs Master Course graduate, and a Karen Pryor Academy Certified Training Partner. She holds a Certificate III in Dog Behaviour & Training and a Certificate IV in Veterinary Nursing. As the proud owner of Trail Sniffers Dog Behaviour and Training, she has dedicated her professional life to helping dogs and their guardians navigate, train, and advocate for their needs.

Camille’s goal is to empower guardians with the knowledge and skills they need to create a harmonious and loving relationship with their dog. Her training methodology is based on a force-free, scientific, and evidence-based approach, and she believes in nurturing positive and respectful relationships.

Follow Trail Sniffers on Facebook and Instagram at @trailsniffers.

Related Stories

Calm Leash Walks: A Science-Based Guide to Managing Your Reactive Dog's Stress

• Facebook
• Twitter
• Pinterest