The Realities of Rescue Dogs: Is Adopting Right for You?

Written by Australian Dog Lover 10:09:00 - 0 Comments

As paws and feet hit the pavement later this month for the RSPCA’s iconic Million Paws Walk, we’re reminded of its mission: to rally support for thousands of dogs in shelters across Australia. Last financial year alone, nearly 17,500 dogs found refuge with the RSPCA*, and many Aussies stepped up to give them a second chance at life – but this isn’t a decision to be taken lightly.

Best-selling author, founder of The Canine Perspective and canine behaviourist Sarah Rutten said adopting a rescue dog can be a life-changing experience and for some people, this journey is a perfect fit; but for others, it may be overwhelming and that’s okay.

“Past neglect and abandonment can weigh heavily on rescue dogs – sometimes manifesting as reactivity, anxiety and unique needs that may not be the right fit for every home,” Sarah said.

“Even puppies, while generally quicker to adapt if re-homed between the ages of seven and nine weeks, may still carry unseen trauma.”

“As rewarding as adopting from a shelter can be, it’s crucial that your chosen pup suits your lifestyle, household and experience level as their guardian. Before adopting, you should ask yourself: ‘is a rescue dog the right fit for me?’”

Sarah said prospective rescue dog parents should consider:

✔️ Do I have the time and emotional resources to build trust with a dog who may have trauma, anxiety or behavioural quirks?

✔️ Am I open to working with a trainer or canine behaviour expert if needed?

✔️ Is my household ready to support the dog's needs, even if progress is slow?

For those ready for the journey, Sarah said the foundation of a strong, lasting relationship with a rescue dog lies in patience, structure and trust.

4 Tips for Helping Your New Rescue Dog Adjust:

#1. Patience is Key

Trust cannot be rushed – especially for dogs with a traumatic past.

“Many pups from shelters can arrive at their new homes in a shut-down and withdrawn state,” Sarah said. “Once they start to relax in their new environment, cheeky, boundary-pushing behaviours may emerge – this is actually very mentally healthy and a sign that their nervous system is starting to settle.

“Be patient and make sure you use lots of treats and praise to reinforce the behaviours that you’d like to see repeated.”

#2. Build a Bond Before Training

Before expecting perfect recall or a great handshake, focus on strengthening the relationship with simple, positive interactions like snuggling calmly together on the couch.

“There's a reason why many new dog parents struggle to get their rescue dogs to come when called," Sarah said. "It's not the dog’s fault – it's most likely that the human-dog bond hasn’t had a chance to fully form yet."

#3. Follow a Structured Routine

A clear, predictable daily routine provides a sense of stability for dogs coming from uncertain backgrounds.

Our rescue pup Porthos decided from Day 1
that the safest space was under our desk!
“Dogs like routine – they feel safe and comforted when they know what to expect,” Sarah said. “If possible, try feeding and walking them at the same time each day to build that sense of security.”

#4. Create a Safe Space

It’s important for every dog to have a safe space to retreat and decompress, but even more so for rescue pups.

“Whether it’s a crate tucked away from the main living areas or a comfy corner, the goal is to create a calm, stress-free spot for your dog to rest without being disturbed,” Sarah said.

Choosing the Right Path For You and Your Future Pup

Sarah said rescue dogs can have the potential to thrive, but they need adopters who are willing to be patient enough to let them heal, one step at a time.

“There is no shame in thoughtfully choosing a dog from a registered, reputable breeder if that’s the best match for your situation instead,” she said.

"What matters most is making a compassionate, honest choice that will help ensure that every dog, whether rescued or purchased, finds a loving, stable, and lifelong home.”

For more expert dog behaviour and training advice, visit www.thecanineperspective.com.au

* RSPCA (2025), Animal Outcomes From Our Shelters: Care and Adoption Centres 2023-24, https://rspca.sfo2.cdn.digitaloceanspaces.com/public/Uploads/annual-statistics/RSPCA-Australia-Annual-Statistics-2023-2024.pdf

About The Canine Perspective:

The Canine Perspective founder Sarah Rutten is not just another dog trainer – she's a thought leader pushing for real change in how humans and dogs understand.

With a no-nonsense, science-backed approach, she's on a mission to educate dog owners, challenge outdated training myths, and advocate for ethical, force-free methods that strengthen the human-dog bond.

Follow Sarah Rutten and the Canine Perspective: